Sacred Activism vs. Savior Complex: Why Social Justice Needs Indigenous Wisdom

Part 2: Learning from Indigenous Wisdom

In Part 1, we examined how well-intentioned activism can perpetuate colonial patterns through the White Savior Complex. Now we turn to Indigenous wisdom for a transformative alternative.

Indigenous Wisdom on Authentic Solidarity

Indigenous movements offer profound teachings on authentic solidarity that challenge dominant culture's individualistic approach to social change. These teachings emphasize that "finding our way to a reciprocal relationship with our planet must involve a return to Indigenous ways of living" based on relationship rather than dominance.

Relationship Over Transaction: Indigenous activism is grounded in building long-term relationships rather than engaging in short-term interventions. This means showing up consistently, not just during crises. It means learning people's names, understanding their histories, and committing to the long arc of liberation rather than seeking quick victories or photo opportunities.

Reciprocity Over Charity: Sacred activism rejects the charity model where some give and others receive. Instead, it operates from understanding that everyone has gifts to offer and needs to be met. These organizations understand that Indigenous communities aren't just victims needing help, but teachers offering wisdom essential for everyone's survival.

Humility Over Heroism: Indigenous wisdom emphasizes the helper's need for transformation. True solidarity requires examining how we benefit from systems of oppression and committing to our own decolonization. This is uncomfortable work that challenges the hero narrative so prevalent in activist culture.

Learning from Indigenous-Led Movements

The most effective social justice movements of recent decades have been those led by Indigenous communities using traditional organizing principles. The fight against the Dakota Access Pipeline exemplifies sacred activism in practice:

Community-Led Strategy: The resistance was planned and directed by Indigenous water protectors, not outside organizations. Allies were welcomed but expected to follow Indigenous leadership rather than impose their own agendas.

Spiritual Foundation: The camps operated according to Indigenous spiritual principles, with ceremonies, prayers, and sacred fire at the center of organizing, shaping how people related to each other and the land they were defending.

Long-term Relationship Building: The movement built on decades of relationship-building among Indigenous communities rather than appearing in response to a single crisis. These relationships enabled sustained resistance even when media attention faded.

Teaching While Fighting: The camps became schools where non-Indigenous allies learned Indigenous history, culture, and organizing principles. Education was understood as integral to justice work, not separate from it.

Indigenous Principles for Authentic Solidarity

Indigenous communities offer specific guidance for how allies can practice sacred activism rather than perpetuating savior complex:

• Follow Indigenous Leadership: In movements affecting Indigenous communities, Indigenous people must be in leadership positions with decision-making authority, not just ceremonial roles or advisory positions.

• Do Your Own Work: Allies must educate themselves about Indigenous history and current realities rather than expecting Indigenous people to provide basic education. This includes learning whose traditional territory you live on and what happened there.

• Examine Your Motivation: Are you acting from ego needs or genuine commitment to liberation? Sacred activism requires ongoing self-examination about why you're involved and what you're getting from the work.

• Think in Generations: Indigenous organizing operates on seven-generation timescales, considering the impact of today's decisions on children not yet born. This long-term thinking challenges activist culture's focus on immediate results.

• Practice Reciprocity: What are you learning from Indigenous communities? How are you being transformed by the relationship? Authentic solidarity changes everyone involved.

• Understand Your Own Racial/Ethnic Identity: Sacred activism begins with self-knowledge. Understand how your own racial and ethnic background shapes your perspective and influences how you show up in Indigenous spaces.

• Accept Limitations of Understanding: Recognize that you will never fully understand how it feels to be NDN. This humility is essential for authentic solidarity without appropriation.

• Consider the Personal and Social Costs: Authentic solidarity may require sacrifices of comfort, status, or relationships. Be prepared for these costs rather than abandoning the work when it becomes difficult.

• Wait to be Invited: Respect tribal sovereignty and community boundaries by waiting to be invited in, or at minimum, asking permission with appropriate cultural protocols (such as offering tobacco).

• Distinguish History from Mythology: Educate yourself on American History versus American Myth, particularly regarding Indigenous peoples. Understanding this distinction helps dismantle colonial narratives.

• Listen to Indigenous Voices: Prioritize listening to North American Indigenous peoples, especially elders, without interruption or defensive reactions.

• Practice Disciplined Speech: Don't speak unless asked to do so. Similarly, don't offer apologies unless specifically requested, as these can center your feelings rather than Indigenous needs.

• Speak to Your Own Community: Use your voice and privilege to address injustices when speaking to your own people group, taking the burden of education off Indigenous communities.

• Accept Your Role as Junior Partner: Understand that authentic solidarity means accepting a supporting role rather than leadership or direction-setting positions.

• Embrace Discomfort: Get comfortable with discomfort, including NDN humor that may challenge your perspectives or self-image.

• Release Need for Recognition: Learn to love the lack of public recognition or credit for your contributions, avoiding the spotlight that belongs to Indigenous leaders.

• Find Integrity in the Work: Take satisfaction in living a life of personal and social integrity rather than seeking external validation for your activism.

Progressive Activism's Colonial Blind Spots

Progressive settler organizations often dismiss Indigenous wisdom as "spiritual" or "cultural" while unconsciously replicating colonial patterns in their organizing:

Privileging Academic Knowledge: Settler movements often prioritize university-based research over traditional knowledge systems, reproducing academic colonialism that dismisses Indigenous ways of knowing.

Individual Rights Framework: Liberal human rights discourse focuses on individual rights rather than collective relationships, making it difficult to understand Indigenous concepts of sovereignty and self-determination.

Separation of Spiritual and Political: Settler activism often treats spirituality and politics as separate realms, missing how Indigenous movements integrate ceremony, prayer, and traditional teachings into organizing strategy.

Urgency Culture: Settler organizations often operate from manufactured urgency that burns out activists and prevents the relationship-building essential for sustainable change.

Transforming Activism Through Indigenous Wisdom

What would social justice movements look like if they truly embraced Indigenous teachings on sacred activism?

Ceremony and Relationship: Movements would begin with ceremony—creating sacred space for the hard work of liberation. They would prioritize relationship-building over campaign tactics, understanding that authentic relationships are the foundation of sustainable change.

Consensus and Council: Decision-making would follow Indigenous council processes that seek consensus rather than majority rule, ensuring that all voices are heard and considered.

Healing and Justice: Movements would integrate healing practices, recognizing that people harmed by oppression need more than policy changes—they need community healing and restoration.

Teaching and Learning: Every action would include educational components, with experienced organizers teaching newcomers and everyone learning from the communities most affected by injustice.

The Transformation of the Helper

Perhaps most importantly, Indigenous wisdom teaches that authentic solidarity transforms the helper as much as the helped. This challenges activist culture's focus on external change while avoiding internal examination.

Sacred activism requires allies to examine their own relationship to privilege, their motivation for involvement, and their assumptions about how change happens. It demands the understanding that how we organize matters as much as what we organize for.

This transformation isn't comfortable. It requires acknowledging that despite good intentions, many of us have been practicing sophisticated forms of colonialism in our activism. It means sitting with the discomfort of not being the hero, not having the answers, not being in control.

But this transformation is also liberating. It frees us from the burden of the savior complex and opens space for authentic relationship. It allows us to learn from communities that have been practicing justice for thousands of years rather than trying to reinvent organizing from scratch.

Conclusion: From Savior to Relative

The choice between sacred activism and savior complex isn't just tactical—it's spiritual. It's the difference between approaching justice work as missionaries or as relatives, between seeing ourselves as rescuers or as part of the web of relationships that needs healing.

Indigenous movements show us that another way is possible. They demonstrate that the most effective activism grows from relationship, operates through reciprocity, and transforms everyone involved. They teach that true solidarity requires not just good intentions but fundamental changes in how we understand ourselves and our place in the world.

For those committed to justice, this wisdom offers both challenge and invitation. The challenge: examine how our activism might be perpetuating the very systems we oppose. The invitation: learn from communities that have been practicing sacred activism since time immemorial.

The world doesn't need more saviors. It needs more relatives—people willing to do the spiritual and political work of authentic solidarity. That work begins with the humility to follow Indigenous leadership and the courage to be transformed by the relationship. Any takers?

---

I am a mixed Indigenous writer of books, screenplays, articles. I explore spirituality, theology, Indigeneity, justice, race, farming. Recovering PhD, Distinguished Professor Emeritus. Speaking and living into healing our world.